Artist M redivivus

General Materials

Rosado v. Wyman, 397 U.S. 397 (1970)
Rosado v Wyman-1

Wright v. City of Roanoke Redevelopment and Housing Authority, 479 U.S. 418 (1987)
Wright v City of Roanoke Redevelopment and Housing Authority

Wilder v. Virginia Hospital Association, 496 U.S. 498 (1990)
Wilder v Virginia Hosp Assn

Suter v. Artist M., 503 U.S. 347 (1992)
Suter v Artist M

Blessing v. Freestone, 520 U.S. 329 (1997)
Blessing v Freestone

Oral argument transcript, Jan. 6, 1997


Gonzaga University v. Doe, 536 U.S. 273 (2002)
Gonzaga University v Doe

Sanchez v. Johnson, 416 F.3d 1051 (9th Cir. 2005)

VOPA v. Stewart, 563 U.S. 247 (2011)

Virginia Office for Protection and Advocacy v Stewart.doc

Armstrong v. Exceptional Child Center, No. 14-15, transcript of oral argument (January 20, 2015)

Armstrong v. Exceptional Child Center, No. 14-15, 135 S.Ct. 1378 (March 31, 2015)
Armstrong v Exceptional Child Center Inc

42 U.S.C. sec. 1320a-2
42 U.S.C. sec. 1320a-2

42 U.S.C. sec. 1320a-10
42 U.S.C. sec. 1320a-10

LH, H. Conf. Rep. No. 103-761 (1994) at 926, reprinted in 1994 USCCAN 2901, 3257.
multiethnic placement

H.R. Rep. No. 102-631 (Ways & Means) at 364-67. Revenue Act of 1992; 1992 CIS H783-13, 5 fiches, page 1 (cover, fiche 1) plus pages 364-67 (fiche 4)
H.R. Rep. No. 102-631

138 Cong. Rec. 34090 (Oct. 8, 1992) (Sen. Riegle)
138 Cong. Rec. 34090

139 Cong. Rec. 5571 introducing S. 620 (March 18, 1993) (Sen. Riegle)
139 Cong. Rec. 5571

Cover, Federal Judicial Review of State Welfare Practices, 67 Columbia L. Rev. 84 (1967)
Federal Judicial Review of State Welfare Practices-1

NWRO v. Finch, 429 F.2d 725 (D.C. Cir. 1970)
The National Welfare Rights Organization et al

Connecticut DPW v. HEW, 448 F.2d 209 (2d Cir. 1971)

Connecticut State Dept of Public Welfare v Department of Health Ed and Welfare Social and Rehabilita

Arizona DPW v. HEW, 449 F.2d 456 (9th Cir. 1971)
Arizona State Dept of Public Welfare v Department of Health Ed and Welfare.rtf
Arizona State Dept of Public Welfare v Department of Health Ed and Welfare-1

Almenares v. Wyman, 453 F.2d 1075 (2d Cir. 1971)
Almenares v Wyman-1

Tomlinson and Mashaw, Enforcement of Federal Standards in Grant-in-Aid Programs: Suggestions for Beneficiary Involvement,58 Virginia Law Review 600 (1972)

Enforcement of Federal Standards in Federal Grant-in Aid Programs

Perkins, Pin the Tail on the Donkey, 9 St. Louis Univ. Journal of Health Law & Policy 207 (2016)

CMS, “Medicaid Program; Methods for Assuring Access to Covered Medicaid Services—Exemptions for States With High Managed Care Penetration Rates and Rate Reduction Threshold,” 83 Fed. Reg. 12696 (March 23, 2018).

1902(a)(23) Cases

Dear State Medicaid Director 16-5, April 19, 2016

Dear State Medicaid Director 18-3, Jan. 19, 2018


[South Carolina memo supporting motion to dismiss, August 20, 2018]

[SC memo dism]

Planned Parenthood South Atlantic v. Baker, No. 3:18-cv-2078 (D. S.C.), 326 F.Supp.3d 39 (August 28, 2018)

PPSA v. Baker PI

Appeal, No. 18-2133

[Planned Parenthood opposition to dismissal, September 4, 2018]

[PP dism op]

[US reply supporting dismissal, September 11, 2018]

[US reply dism]

Appellant’s opening brief, 11/26/2018

4C PPSA v. Baker appellant’s opening brief

Appellees’ brief, 1/14/2019

4c pp appellees’ brief

Reproductive rights organizations amicus, 1/22/2019

4c reproductive rights orgzs amicus

NHeLP amicus, 1/22/2019

4c nhelp amicus

Appellant’s opposition to amicus filings, 2/4/2019

4C opposition to amicus filings

Appellant’s reply brief, 2/4/2019

4C reply brief

Order accepting amicus filings, 2/6/2019

4C order accepting amicus briefs

Opinion, 10/29/2019

4C PP v Baker opinion

SC request to extend time for filing for cert, January 3, 2020

20200103141603867_2020-01-03 SCDHHS PPSAT-Extension of Time Request For Petition for Cert

Extension order for filing for cert to 3/27/20, January 8, 2020

No. 19A752

USC extension to 3 27

[Planned Parenthood motion and memo for summary judgment, January 31, 2020]


[South Carolina memo opposing summary judgment, February 24, 2020]

[SC MSJ op]

[Planned Parenthood summary judgment reply, February 28, 2020]

[PP SJ reply]

Order re cert procedures, March 19, 2020


[Opinion denying motion to dismiss, March 23, 2020]

[M dism denial]

Petition for certiorari, March 27, 2020 (No. 19-1186)

20200327125507902_USSC Petition for Writ of Certiorari

Motion to extend time for response to 5/29, April 24, 2020

20200424101633944_SC Medicaid Opp Cert Extension

Apr 24 2020 Motion to extend the time to file a response is granted and the time is extended to and including May 29, 2020.

American Center for Law and Justice amicus, April 29, 2020

20200429102735438_Baker v Edwards – Amicus brief

Family Policy Councils amicus, April 29, 2020

20200429123128336_Baker v. Edwards FPC Amici brief 4-29-20

Nebraska, Indiana, and 17 other states amicus, April 29, 2020

20200429123619148_Baker – 19-1186 – Amici States Brief

Americans United for Life amicus, April 29, 2020

20200429124844771_19-1186 Amicus Brief of American United for Life

137 Members of Congress amicus, April 29, 2020


86 current and 2 former SC Legislators amicus, April 29, 2020

20200429152003850_Amicus Brief

Motion for extension of time to respond, May 21, 2020

20200521133704170_SC Medicaid Opp Cert Extension2

May 22 2020 Motion to extend the time to file a response is granted and the time is further extended to and including June 29, 2020.

Motion for extension of time to respond, June 18, 2020

20200618095446571_SC Medicaid Opp Cert Extension3_

Jun 19 2020 Motion to extend the time to file a response is granted and the time is further extended to and including July 29, 2020

Opposition to petition for certiorari, July 29, 2020

20200729181358162_Baker v PP Brief in Opp FINAL

Petitioner’s motion to delay distribution, August 6, 2020

20200806193755957_Request for delay of distribution date

Aug 07 2020 Motion to delay distribution of the petition for a writ certiorari until September 16, 2020, granted.

Petitioner’s reply, September 15, 2020

20200915103650182_19-1186 Reply Brief

[Trial court summary judgment opinion, September 17, 2020]

[PP v. Baker SJ order]

Respondents’ supplemental brief on mootness, September 22, 2020

20200922184224203_Baker v PP Supplemental Brief

Petitioners’ supplemental brief, October 8, 2020

20201008152609789_19-1186 Response to Supplemental Brief

Cert denied, October 13, 2020


Stipulation to dismiss additional counts, December 11, 2020

PP v Baker stip to dismiss addl counts

Judgment, December 11, 2020

PP v Baker judgment 12 11 20

12/14/2020 76 TEXT ORDER Vacating 75 Judgment. Signed by Honorable Mary Geiger Lewis on 12/14/2020. (cbru, ) (Entered: 12/14/2020)

Declaratory judgment and permanent injunction, December 14, 2020

decl j perm i

South Carolina notice of appeal, January 8, 2021


Appeal #2 file number, 21-1043

Briefing order, January 26, 2021

4C briefing order

Phillip opening brief, March 29, 2021

4C2 Phillip OB

Appellees’ brief, May 28, 2021

4C appellees brief

Reproductive Rights and Justice Organizations amicus, June 3, 2021

4C reproductive rights and justice orgz amicus

National Health Law Program amicus, June 4, 2021

4C NHeLP amicus

American Academy of Family Physicians amicus, June 4, 2021

4C American Acad Fam P amicus

Reply brief, July 2, 2021

4C SC reply brief

Plaintiffs’ request to file surreply, July 30, 2021

4C pltf rq surreply

Order requesting response to plaintiffs’ request, August 2, 2021

4C order rqg response

Appellants’ response re mootness, August 12, 2021

4C SC response re mootness

Order, August 13, 2021

4C order carrying surreply to merits

SC additional authority (Hirschfeld), September 24, 2021

4C SC addl auth Hirschfeld

US response to SC additional authority, September 29, 2021

4C US response H


Planned Parenthood of Greater Texas v. Smith, No. 1:15-cv-1058 (W.D. Tex.), on appeal, No. 17-50282 (5th Cir.)

PI opinion, 2/4/17
PPGT v Smith PI order 16942750-0–28141

Opening brief, 8/7/17
5C PPGT 17-50282 appellant’s brief

42 Members amicus, 8/14/17
5C PPGT 17-50282 42 MC amicus

Donovan amicus, 8/17/17
5C PPGT 17-50282 Donovan amicus

Eagle Forum amicus, 8/14/17
5C PPGT 17-50282 Eagle Forum amicus

Bryant amicus, 8/14/17
5C PPGT Bryant amicus

Appellees’ brief, 10/6/17
5C PPGT 17-50282 appellees’ brief

Black Mamas Matter amicus, 10/13/17
5C PPGT 17-50282 BMM amicus

NHeLP amicus, 10/13/17
28_17-50282_Brief of Amici Curiae NHeLP et al.filestampaccepted

25 Senators’ amicus, 10/13/17
5C PPGT 17-50282 US Sen amicus brief

Appellants’ reply brief, 11/17/17
5C PPGT 17-50282 reply brief

Opinion, 1/17/19


Texas petition for rehearing en banc, 1/31/19

5C PP v. Smith Tex petition for rehearing en banc

Texas Fifth Circuit motion to vacate District Court injunction, February 1, 2019


Fifth Circuit en banc and scheduling order, February 4, 2019

5C order for rehearing en banc

Fifth Circuit Planned Parenthood op to stay, February 4, 2019

5C PP v. Smith op to motion to stay

Fifth Circuit order directing reply re motion to vacate, February 5, 2019

5C PP v. Smith order directing reply

Fifth Circuit order denying petition for rehearing en banc as moot, February 5, 2019

5C PP v. Smith order denying petition rheb as moot

Appellants’ reply supporting motion to vacate, February 7, 2019

5C PP v. Smith reply supporting motion to vacate

Order transferring motion to vacate to en banc review, February 15, 2019

5C order carrying motion to stay dc injunction with case

Appellants’ en banc brief, March 7, 2019

5C PP v. Smith appellants’ en banc brief

Amicus — Louisiana, Mississippi, March 14, 2019

LA MS amicus

Amicus — Sens. Cruz and Cornyn, March 14, 2019

Cruz Cornyn amicus

Amicus — Alliance Defending Freedom, March 14, 2019 (5th Cir. denied motion for leave to file)

ADF amicus

Amicus — with motion, Eagle Forum, March 14, 2019

Eagle Forum motion and amicus

Order on amicus briefing, March 19, 2019

17-50282_order on amicus briefing

04/05/2019 CASE CALENDARED for En Banc rehearing on Tuesday, 05/14/2019 in New Orleans In accordance with our policy, lead counsel only will receive via email at a later date a copy of the court’s docket and an acknowledgment form. All other counsel of record should monitor the court’s website for the posting of the oral argument calendars. [17-50282] (SME) [Entered: 04/05/2019 01:10 PM]

Appellees’ supplemental brief, April 8, 2019

5C PP v. Smith appellees’ en banc supplemental brief

18 Senators’ amicus, April 15, 2019

5C senators amicus

NHeLP amicus, April 15, 2019

5C NHeLP amicus

Texas additional authority — Herrera v. Wyoming, June 3, 2019

addl authority wyoming herrera

PP supplemental authority — Baker, November 4, 2019

5C PP supp auth Baker

Texas response to Baker, November 7, 2019

5C Texas Baker addl auth response

Plaintiffs’ additional authority (South Carolina), October 19, 2020

5C pltf addl auth (SC)

US response to additional authority (South Carolina), October 20, 2020

4C US addl auth response

En banc opinion, November 23, 2020

5C en banc opinion 11 23 20

[Technical revision, November 24, 2020]

5C en banc opinion technical revision

Legacy Community Health Services v. Smith, 881 F.3d 358 (5th Cir. 2018), discussed in the en banc opinion

Legacy Community Health Services Incorporated v Smith.doc

Hawkins withdrawal, January 29, 2021

5C Hawkins exit

Planned Parenthood of Gulf Coast v. Gee, No. 3:15-cv-00565 (M.D. La.), on appeal, No. 17-30987 (5th Cir.), No. 17-1492

Fifth Circuit opinion, 9/14/16

Fifth Circuit opinion 6/29/17

States’ amicus brief supporting rehearing en banc, 7/24/17
5C PPG states’ rhb amicus

PP letter re Does v. Gillespie additional authority, 8/21/17
5C PPGee 8C add auth response

Dissent from denial of rehearing en banc, 11/28/17
PP v. Gee RHB

Cert extension request, 1/30/18
20180130181422949_DHH – PPGC DRAFT Cert Extension Motion

Supreme Court order extending time for filing for cert, 2/6/18
PP v Gee cert extension

Cert petition, 4/27/18
20180427135540119_Gee v Planned Parenthood_cert. petition_PDF-a

Amicus, 27 family organizations, 5/31/18
20180531124951132_17-1492 Amicus Brief of Twenty-Seven Family Policy Organizations

Amicus, 90 members of Congress, 5/31/18
20180531140245033_17-1492 Amcus BrIef of 90 Members of Congress

Amicus, Indiana, 5/31/18
20180531152126434_Brief of Indiana et. al. as Amici Curiae in Support of Petitioner

Amicus, ACLJ, 5/31/18
20180531164747384_Gee v PPGC Amicus ACLJ

Cert opposition, 7/2/2018
20180702130527612_Gee v. Planned Parenthood Brief in Opposition

Cert reply, 8/2/2018
20180802114632261_Gee v Planned Parenthood reply brief_pdfA

Cert denied, 12/10/2018



Harris v. Olszewski, 442 F.3d 456 (6th Cir. 2006)

See Planned Parenthood of Greater Ohio v. Hodges, 201 F.Supp.3d 898 (S.D. Ohio 2016), aff’d sub nom Planned Parenthood of Greater Ohio v. Himes, _ F.3d _,
2018 WL 1833196 (6th Cir., April 18, 2018), rev’d, 3/12/19


Planned Parenthood of Indiana v. Commissioner, 699 F.3d 962 (7th Cir. 2012)

Planned Parenthood of Arkansas & Eastern Oklahoma v. Gillespie, No. 4:15-cv-566 (E.D. Ark.), on appeal sub nom. Does v. Gillespie, No. 15-3271 (8th Cir.)

Opening brief, 12/1/15
8C PP appellant opening brief

Appellees’ brief, 1/29/16
8C PP appellee brief

Appellants’ reply brief, 2/26/16
8C PP appellant reply brief

Eighth Circuit opinion, 8/16/17
PPArk v GIllespie 8th cir opin

Petition for rehearing en banc, with exhibits, 8/30/17
8C PP pet rhr en banc

8C PP pet rhr ex 1

8C PP pet rhr ex 2

8C PP pet rhr ex 3

Opposition to petition for rehearing en banc, 10/24/17
Does v. Gillespie rehearing en banc op

Order denying rehearing en banc, 11/13/17
Does v. Gillespie order denying rehearing en banc


Planned Parenthood of Arizona v. Betlach, 727 F.3d 960 (9th Cir. 2013)


Planned Parenthood of Kansas v. Andersen, No. 16-3249 (10th Cir., Feb. 21, 2018), No. 17-1340
10th cir PP opinion

Joint motion to stay the mandate, 3/5/18
Document 9

Petition for certiorari, 3/21/18
20180321141128195_Andersen v. Planned Parenthood of Kansas et al._Petition

Request for extension of time to file response, 4/16/18
20180416145157114_Andersen – Request for Ext.

Americans United for Life cert-stage amicus, 4/23/18
20180423103023537_17-1340 Amicus Brief of American United for Life

Indiana et al cert-stage amicus, 4/23/18
20180423105359150_Brief of Indiana et al. as Amici Curiae in Support of Petitioner

Request for further extension, 5/16/18
20180516132705581_Anderson – Second Letter Request for Extension of Time

Opposition to further extension, 5/16/18
20180516163614026_Kansas Letter re extension

May 22 2018 Motion to further extend the time to file a response denied.

Certiorari opposition, 5/23/18
20180523164304452_17-1340 Brief in Opposition

Certiorari reply, 6/1/18
20180601103631521_17-1340 rb

Certiorari denial, 12/10/18


Other recent 1983 Medicaid cases of interest

Seventh Circuit nursing home case

Talevski v. Health and Hospital Corp. of Marion County, No. 2:19-cv-13 (N.D. Ind., March 26, 2020)


No. 20-1664

Opening brief, July 31, 2020

7C appellant brief

AARP amicus, August 7, 2020

7C AARP amicus

NHeLP amicus, August 7, 2020

7C NHeLP amicus

Law Professors amicus, August 7, 2020

7C Law Professors amicus

Appellee brief, September 29, 2020

7C appellee brief

States’ amicus, October 6, 2020

7C states amicus

Indiana HCA amicus, October 6, 2020

7C IHCA amicus

Reply brief, November 3, 2020

7C reply brief

Ninth Circuit nursing home case

Anderson v. Ghaly, No. 16-16193 (9th Cir., July 18, 2019) [930 F.3d 1066]


Other nursing home cases

Grammer v. John J. Kane Regional Centers-Glen Hazel, 570 F.3d 520 (3d Cir. 2009)


Duncan v. Johnson-Mathers Health Care, Inc., No. 5:09-cv-417 (E.D. Ky., July 28, 2010)


Liptak v. Ramsey County, No. 0:16-cv-225 (D. Minn., Sept. 23, 2016)

Liptak opinion

Shanklin v. Coulee Med. Ctr., No. 2:17-cv-377 (E.D. Wash., April 15, 2019)

Shanklin dismissal

Other 1983 cases of interest

Second Circuit foster care maintenance payments case

New York State Citizens’ Coalition for Children v. Poole, No. 14-2919 (2d Cir., April 19, 2019) [922 F.3d 69]

14-2919Comp_opn 2

Motion for extension of time within which to seek rehearing en banc, April 26, 2019

5983378-0–1342314-2919 rh en banc xt request

Petition for rehearing en banc, June 3, 2019

2C petition rheb

Order denying rehearing en banc, with Livingston and Cabranes dissents, August 16, 2019

2C order denying rheb

2C Livingston dissent

2C Cabranes dissent

Cert petition, No. 19-574 (Oct. 30, 2019)

20191030180318056_Poole v NYSCCC_Petition for Writ

Connecticut and other states amicus supporting cert, Dec. 2, 2019

20191202134552318_19-574 Poole v NYSCCC State Amici Brief 12-2-2019 FINAL

Cert opposition, Jan. 2, 2020

20200102121349135_NYSCCC BIO 1.2.2020

Cert reply, Jan. 9, 2020

20200109154057873_19-574 Reply Brief

Cert denied, Jan. 27, 2020

Other foster care payments cases

D.O. v. Glisson, 847 F.3d 374 (6th Cir. 2017)

DO v Glisson

Midwest Foster Care and Adoption Ass’n v. Kincade, 712 F.3d 1190 (8th Cir. 2013)

Midwest Foster Care and Adoption Assn v Kincade

California State Foster Parents Ass’n v. Wagner, 624 F.3d 974 (9th Cir. 2010)

California State Foster Parent Assn v Wagner

Foster care records cases

Lynch v. Dukakis, 719 F.2d 504 (1st Cir. 1983)


L.J. by and through Darr v. Massinga, 838 F.2d 118 (4th Cir. 1988)


31 Foster Children v. Bush, 329 F.3d 1255 (11th Cir. 2003)


Henry A. v. Willden, 678 F.3d 991 (9th Cir. 2012)


Estate of Place v. Anderson, 398 F.Supp.3d 816 (D. Colo. 2019)


Vienna Convention cases

U.S. v. Jimenez-Nava, 243 F.3d 192 (5th Cir. 2001)


U.S. v. Emuegbunam, 268 F.3d 377 (6th Cir. 2001)


Cornejo v. County of San Diego, 504 F.3d 853 (9th Cir. 2007)


Mora v. New York, 524 F.3d 183 (2d Cir. 2008)


Gandara v. Bennett, 528 F.3d 823 (11th Cir. 2008)


Earle v. District of Columbia, 707 F.3d 299 (D.C. Cir. 2012)


Waiver programs, and proposals, that would exclude Planned Parenthood


Family Planning Referrals proposal, October 21, 2019


Family Planning Referrals completeness letter, October 28, 2019


South Carolina

Preconception Care proposal, August 23, 2018


Preconception Care completeness letter, September 6, 2018



TennCare II Amendment 36 request, August 10, 2018



Healthy Texas Women proposal, June 28, 2017


Healthy Texas Women completeness letter, July 5, 2017


Healthy Texas Women approval, January 22, 2020


Talevski (suits against private entities)

Talevski v. Health and Hospitals Corp. of Marion County, No. 2:19-cv-13 (N.D. Ind.), No. 20-1664 (7th Cir.)


Opinion and Order, March 26, 2020