Affordable Care Act Litigation

This site includes materials, from the premiumtaxcredits.wikispaces.com and subsidieson1321cexchanges.wikispaces.com sites, copied over in September 2018.

Right now, things are organized in sub-pages; here are some links that might help get from one sub-page to another.

But first, a recently-released article on Affordable Care Act litigation — based partly on this web site.

Gluck-Reagan-Turret_The-Affordable-Care-Act’s-Litigation-Decade

And, second, a link to a short-term calendar of ACA litigation events:

an-aca-litigation-calendar-for-october-2020-through-march-2021-2-27

I’ll do my best to update this every couple of days.  Here, for nostalgia purposes, is the most elephantine of earlier versions, last updated just after the California v. Texas oral argument:

an-aca-litigation-calendar-for-march-through-november-2020-11-10-pm

And, third, a sub-page on “The ACA at 10”

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/aca-at-10-and-other-materials/

The first substantive sub-page deals with “A Global Challenge”: Texas v. U.S., No. 4:18-cv-167 (N.D. Tex.), appeal, No. 19-10011 (5th Cir.), and the declaratory judgment suit, State of Maryland v. U.S., No. 1:18-cv-2849 (D. Md.).

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/a-global-challenge/

Another sub-page, “Whittling away,” presents cases challenging Administration proposals about association health plans, the 2019 regulations, and short-term and limited duration policies.

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/whittling-away/

Then there are sub-pages about enforcing the ACA directly or via section 1557:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/aca-enforcement-directly-and-1557/

About wellness programs:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/wellness-programs

About dialysis:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/dialysis

About the challenges to the religious and moral objections rules:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/religious-and-moral/

And about miscellaneous pending ACA/health cases:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/miscellaneous-aca-litigation/

Litigation about health care sharing ministries:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/health-care-sharing-ministries-litigation/

And recent litigation about Title X restrictions:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/title%20x%20program%20integrity/

And recent litigation about the conscience protection regulations:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/statutory-conscience-rights

And litigation filed in June 2020 about special enrollment periods:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/special-enrollment-periods/

Then there are sub-pages about payments to insurers, specifically, CSRs:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/cost-sharing-reductions-payments/

And risk corridors and risk adjustments:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/risk-corridors-and-risk-adjustment/

Then there are four Medicaid sub-pages, one about state-level disputes implicating the Medicaid expansion:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/aca-litigation-state-by-state/

Another about 1115 waivers for “Community Engagement”: proposals for work requirement disqualifications, lifetime limits, and other prohibitions :

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/1115-medicaid-waivers-community-engagement/

A third about 1115 ‘block grant’ waivers, such as the one semi-proposed for Alaska, and semi-tried-out in Rhode Island

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/medicaid-1115-block-grant-waiver

And the fourth, “Artist M. redivivus,” about whether Medicaid Act rights are enforceable:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/artist-m-redivivus/

I have also added a page with some information about the public charge litigation:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/public-charge-disability-claims

Then, of course, a collection of cases that are now closed, such as King v. Burwell, Halbig, Pruitt, Indiana v. I.R.S; and Ohio and West Virginia [The King Supreme Court briefing and orders from the other Halbig-type premium tax credits cases are up, but other materials from the Halbig-type cases are not up]:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/closed-aca-cases/

Separately, here’s an incomplete collection of Supreme Court briefing in NFIB v. Sebelius:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/nfib-v-sebelius-supreme-court-briefing/

Here is a sub-page on the ACA’s legislative history:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/aca-legislative-history/

And on the recent repeal/replace/repair efforts in Congress:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/repeal-replace-repair/

And there is now an already-copied-over sub-page about section 1332:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/1332-2/

And, finally, a page about miscellaneous pending ACA/health cases:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/miscellaneous-aca-litigation/

Added to the site in November 2020, a page about the transition:

https://affordablecareactlitigation.com/transition-2020-2021/

Here is a crib sheet, originally compiled December 21, 2018, and last updated December 5, 2020, showing the cases I’m trying actively to track.  Gray: not tracking very actively.

A crib sheet, 12/5/2020

Central California

8:19-cv-905

8:19-cv-2105

Eastern California

2:20-cv-867

Northern California

3:17-cv-183

4:17-cv-5783

3:19-cv-1184

3:19-cv-1195

3:19-cv-2405

3:19-cv-2769

3:19-cv-2916

4:19-cv-4717

4:19-cv-4975

4:19-cv-4980

Southern California

3:16-cv-501

3:16-cv-2408

Colorado

1:20-cv-102

1:20-cv-2130

Connecticut

3:19-cv-1098

Delaware

1:19-cv-2103

District of Columbia

1:18-cv-152

1:18-cv-1747

1:18-cv-1900

1:18-cv-2133

1:19-cv-773

1:19-cv-2848

1:19-cv-3526

1:19-cv-3619

1:20-cv-119

1:20-cv-1566

1:20-cv-1630

1:21-cv-117

Idaho

1:17-cv-151

Northern Illinois

1:16-cv-10294

1:17-cv-6618

1:19-cv-6334

Northern Indiana

3:18-cv-491

Maine

1:19-cv-100

Maryland

1:18-cv-2364

1:19-cv-1103

8:19-cv-2715

Massachusetts

1:17-cv-11930

1:20-cv-11297

Minnesota

0:16-cv-100

Western Missouri

3:20-cv-5038

New Mexico

1:18-cv-773

Eastern New York

1:16-cv-4756

1:20-cv-2834

Southern New York

1:15-cv-3608

1:19-cv-4676

1:19-cv-5433

1:19-cv-5435

1:19-cv-7777

1:19-cv-7993

1:20-cv-5583

1:20-cv-9144

North Dakota

3:16-cv-386

3:16-cv-416

Oregon

6:19-cv-317

6:19-cv-318

3:19-cv-1743

Eastern Pennsylvania

2:17-cv-4540

Northern Texas

7:15-cv-151

7:16-cv-108

4:18-cv-167

4:18-cv-779

4:18-cv-825

4:19-cv-532

4:19-cv-800

Southern Texas

4:16-cv-307

Eastern Washington

2:18-cv-12

2:19-cv-183

1:19-cv-3040

1:19-cv-3045

4:19-cv-5210

Western Washington

2:17-cv-1609

2:17-cv-1611

2:19-cv-1281

2:20-cv-1105

2:20-cv-1560

Western Wisconsin

3:18-cv-309

D.C. Circuit

19-5094

19-5095

19-5096

19-5097

19-5125

19-5212

19-5293

19-5295

20-5136

20-5193

20-5331

20-5371

First Circuit

18-1514

19-1836

20-1781

21-1076

Second Circuit

18-2583

19-3591

19-3595

19-4254

20-2537

20-3580

20-3827

Third Circuit

17-3752, 18-1253, 19-1129, 19-1189

Fourth Circuit

18-2133

19-1614

19-2222

20-1215

20-2006

21-1043

Fifth Circuit

17-50282

18-10545

18-20440

18-40246

19-10011

19-10754

20-10093

20-11179

Sixth Circuit

18-5897

Seventh Circuit

18-3408

19-3169

20-3150

Eighth Circuit

19-1705

20-3702

20-3709

Ninth Circuit

18-15255

18-35846

18-35892

19-15072, 19-15118, 19-15150

19-15658

19-15974

19-17213

19-35017

19-35386

19-35394

19-35914

19-36020

20-15398

20-16045

20-16802

20-16823

20-16857

20-35044

20-35468

20-35521

20-80005

20-80006

Tenth Circuit

18-2186

Eleventh Circuit

19-14096

Court of Federal Claims

1:16-cv-259

1:16-cv-587

1:16-cv-649

1:16-cv-651

1:16-cv-744

1:16-cv-967

1:16-cv-1199

1:16-cv-1253

1:16-cv-1384

1:16-cv-1418

1:16-cv-1427

1:16-cv-1491

1:16-cv-1501

1:16-cv-1659

1:16-cv-1722

1:17-cv-87

1:17-cv-94

1:17-cv-95

1:17-cv-97

1:17-cv-347

1:17-cv-348

1:17-cv-357

1:17-cv-363

1:17-cv-653

1:17-cv-703

1:17-cv-877

1:17-cv-906

1:17-cv-957

1:17-cv-1070

1:17-cv-1090

1:17-cv-1108

1:17-cv-1155

1:17-cv-1157

1:17-cv-1185

1:17-cv-1233

1:17-cv-1298

1:17-cv-1312

1:17-cv-1350

1:17-cv-1387

1:17-cv-1432

1:17-cv-1542

1:17-cv-1664

1:17-cv-1759

1:17-cv-1850

1:17-cv-1958

1:17-cv-2048

1:17-cv-2057

1:18-cv-5

1:18-cv-94

1:18-cv-96

1:18-cv-110

1:18-cv-136

1:18-cv-143

1:18-cv-241

1:18-cv-282

1:18-cv-333

1:18-cv-334

1:18-cv-373

1:18-cv-491

1:18-cv-608

1:18-cv-1338

1:18-cv-1484

1:18-cv-1623

1:18-cv-1791

1:18-cv-1820

1:18-cv-1983

1:19-cv-568

1:19-cv-569

1:19-cv-1164

1:19-cv-1770

1:20-cv-163

1:20-cv-179

1:20-cv-259

1:20-cv-458

1:20-cv-546

1:20-cv-561

1:20-cv-565

1:20-cv-578

1:20-cv-606

1:20-cv-746

1:20-cv-757

1:20-cv-846

1:20-cv-892

1:20-cv-924

1:20-cv-996

1:20-cv-1000

1:20-cv-1014

1:20-cv-1377

1:20-cv-1686

Federal Circuit

19-1290

19-1302

19-1633

19-2102

20-1286

20-1292

20-1393

20-2254

21-1380

21-1389

21-1688

 

U.S. Supreme Court

18-1023

18-1028

18-1038

18-1192

19-422

19-431

19-454

19-563

19-840

19-841

19-1019

19-1038

19-1053

19-1186

19-1280

20-37

20-38

20-429

20-449

20-450

20-454

20-539