Title X ‘program integrity’

DHHS, “Compliance With Statutory Program Integrity Requirements,” 84 Fed. Reg. 7714 (March 4, 2019)

2019-03461

 

Cases: California, Maine, Oregon, Eastern Washington

 

CALIFORNIA

State of California by and through Becerra v. Azar, No. 3:19-cv-1184 (N.D. Cal.)

Complaint, March 4, 2019

file0.272369527063471

Essential Access related case notice, March 11, 2019

file0.21084527139659

Order on related case decision procedure, March 12, 2019

file0.633018808943358

Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Edward M. Chen:

Initial Case Management Conference held on 3/20/2019. Plaintiffs to file motion for preliminary injunction by 3/21/2019. Opposition due by 4/8/2019. Reply due by 4/11/2019. Motion Hearing set for 4/18/2019 12:30 PM in San Francisco, Courtroom 05, 17th Floor before Judge Edward M. Chen. See pdf image for further details.

Total Time in Court: 25 Minutes.
Court Reporter: Katherine Sullivan.

Plaintiff Attorneys: Anna Rich, Michelle Ybarra, Justina Sessions.
Defendant Attorney: Bradley Humphries.

Attachment: Minute Order.
(afmS, COURT STAFF) (Date Filed: 3/20/2019) (Entered: 03/20/2019)

Motion for preliminary injunction, March 21, 2019

file0.456023721062717

Brindis declaration, with attachments

merged_84265_-1-1553791051

Cantwell declaration

file0.217870503236679

Castellano-Garcia declaration

file0.208547182885138

Ferrer declaration

file0.481998908837465

Forer declaration

file0.559843778881383

Kost declaration

file0.53189991325247

Marshall declaration

file0.369310351825458

McCarthy declaration

file0.493592401306284

McKinney declaration

file0.847987469091219

Morris declaration

file0.524813505393592

Nestor declaration

file0.907301180103001

Rabinovitz declaration

file0.550208408656669

Rich declaration, with attachments

Declaration of Anna Rich in Support of 26 MOTION for Preliminary Injunction filed byState of California. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit OPA Program Requirements, # 2 Exhibit California Medical Association, # 3 Exhibit Center for Reproductive Rights, # 4 Exhibit American Academy of Nursing, # 5 Exhibit Guttmacher Institute, # 6 Exhibit California Association for Nurse Practitioners, # 7 Exhibit American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, # 8 Exhibit Multistate Comment Letter, # 9 Exhibit American Medical Association, # 10 Exhibit American College of Nurse-Midwives, # 11 Exhibit American Public Health Association, # 12 Exhibit National Family Planning & Reproductive Health Association, # 13 Exhibit Planned Parenthood Federation of America, # 14 Exhibit American Academy of Pediatrics and the Society for Adolescent Health and Medicine, # 15 Exhibit Northeast Valley Health Corporation, # 16 Exhibit American College of Physicians, # 17 Exhibit American Academy of Family Physicians)(Related document(s) 26 ) (Rich, Anna) (Filed on 3/21/2019) (Entered: 03/21/2019)

merged_45092_-1-1553790899

Spirtos declaration

file0.0390669734134796

Thomas declaration

file0.306448458033753

Tosh declaration

file0.224318126487685

Tuttle declaration

file0.981828050493402

Wilburn declaration

file0.229754088717652

Sevier motion to intervene, memo, March 28, 2019

merged_38799_-1-1553896170

merged_78461_-1-1553896229

Institute for Policy Integrity amicus papers, April 5, 2019

merged_25471_-1-1554572380

Ohio amicus, April 8, 2019

merged_24016_-1-1554817225

US opposition, April 8, 2019

merged_69357_-1-1554817385

American Academy of Pediatrics amicus, April 8, 2019

merged_18827_-1-1554817486

Susan B. Anthony List amicus, April 9, 2019

file0.256242994490218

ACLJ amicus, April 10, 2019

merged_63239_-1-1554990205

Plaintiffs’ reply supporting preliminary injunction, April 11, 2019

file0.842454133127955

US opposition to Sevier intervention, April 11, 2019

file0.795303978529898

Plaintiff’s opposition to Sevier intervention, April 11, 2019

file0.776322153202397

Plaintiff’s preliminary injunction reply, April 11, 2019

file0.852687233631638

Order for supplemental submissions re rulemaking, April 15, 2019

file0.700338528995541

US supplemental submission, April 17, 2019

file0.438760244325874

Plaintiffs’ supplemental submission, April 17, 2019

file0.115437460868758

Opinion, April 26, 2019

show_temp.pl 13

Defendants’ notice re conscience regs, May 2, 2019

file0.0442223714582148

Defendants’ notice of appeal, May 6, 2019

file0.159608843076182

Motion for stay pending appeal, with affidavit and proposed order, May 6, 2019

merged_68327_-1-1557236485

Motion for shortened time, with affidavit and proposed order, May 6, 2019

merged_13912_-1-1557236537

[Many amicus briefs, May 7, 2019]

Plaintiff’s opposition to motion for shortened time, with declaration and proposed order, May 8, 2019

file0.00161229822891684

file0.266690654252795

file0.953011291605559

Order denying stay but modifying injunction, May 8, 2019

file0.831715888382075

 

Essential Access Health v. Azar, No. 4:19-cv-1195 (N.D. Cal.)

Complaint, March 4, 2019

file0.396526843114895

Certification of interested entities or persons, March 11, 2019

file0.790779641402093

Motion for preliminary injunction/proposed order, March 21, 2019

merged_3177_-1-1553262107

Ybarra declaration, with attachments

merged_80776_-1-1553535455

For other versions of the Rabinovitz, Marshall, Kost, Brindis, Ferrer, Forer, Tosh, Wilburn, Thomas, Nestor, McKinney, Spirtos file0.608165015970496, Castellano-Garcia, Tuttle, and McCarthy declarations, see above.

For other versions of the US opposition, American Academy of Pediatrics amicus, April 8, see above

For other versions of the reply, April 11, 2019, see above

 

MAINE

Family Planning Ass’n of Maine v. Azar, No. 1:19-cv-100 (D. Maine)

Complaint, filed March 6, 2019

Maine Family Planning complaint

Motion for preliminary injunction, with memo and declarations, March 25, 2019

Maine FP PI mo

Maine FP PI memo

[]

American Academy of Pediatrics et al amicus,

 

Alabama et al amicus,

 

Opposition to motion for preliminary injunction, April 15, 2019

Maine FP US PI op

Americans United for Life amicus,

 

Reply memo supporting preliminary injunction, April 23, 2019

Maine FP PI reply

 

 

 

OREGON

State of Oregon v. Azar, No. 6:19-cv-317 (D. Or.)

Complaint, filed March 5, 2019

6521125-0–16763

States’ motion for preliminary injunction, March 21, 2019

6542524-0–10163

Alexander-Scott declaration

 

Alifante declaration

 

Anderson declaration

 

Brandt declaration

 

Byrd declaration

 

Camp declaration

 

Charest declaration

 

Childs-Roshak declaration

 

Cooke declaration

 

Darney declaration

 

David declaration

 

Drew declaration

 

Gallagher declaration

 

Gillespie declaration

 

Handler declaration

 

Holmes declaration

 

Keenan declaration

 

Kunkel declaration

 

Lightner declaration

 

Lytle-Barnaby declaration

 

MacNaughton declaration

 

Nelson declaration

 

Preiss declaration

 

Rattay declaration

 

Reece declaration

 

Rimberg declaration

 

Ross declaration

 

Schaler-Haynes declaration

 

Skinner declaration

 

Stephens declaration

 

Tobias declaration

 

Walker Harris declaration

 

Wilson declaration

 

Zoll declaration

 

ACOG amicus, April 9, 2019

6561761-0–5535

Ohio amicus, April 11, 2019

merged_22311_-1-1555075424

US opposition to motion for preliminary injunction, April 11, 2019

6565219-0–20009

Private plaintiffs’ preliminary injunction reply, April 19, 2019

6574248-0–29596

Declaration

State plaintiffs’ preliminary injunction reply, April 19.2019

6574324-0–27966

Declarations

 

Plaintiffs’ notice re PI in Eastern Washington case, April 25, 2019

Oregon plaintiffs notice re suppl authority 4 25

Defendants’ response re PI, April 26, 2019

Oregon defendants notice re suppl authority 4 26

Plaintiffs’ reply re PI, April 26, 2019

Oregon plaintiffs joint reply re suppl authority 4 26

Order for preliminary injunction, April 29, 2019

6584696-0–25895

Defendants’ notice re conscience regulations, May 2, 2019

6589287-0–3452

Defendants’ notice of appeal, May 3, 2019

6592069-0–9614

Defendants’ motion for stay pending appeal, May 3, 2019

6592290-0–9853

Johnson declaration supporting motion for stay, May 3, 2019

6592293-0–9931

Ninth Circuit # 19-35386

05/06/2019 152 ORDER: Defendants ask the Court to stay the nationwide injunction entered last week. In their motion, Defendants specifically request that “If upon reviewing this motion the Court does not believe Defendants have met the requirements for a stay, Defendants request that the Court summarily deny the motion without awaiting a response from Plaintiffs.” The Court respectfully disagrees with defendants’ position and, in accordance with their request, summarily denies the motion to stay 150 in case 6:19-cv-00317-MC; 143 in case 6:19-cv-00318-MC. without awaiting a response from plaintiffs. Ordered by Judge Michael J. McShane. Associated Cases: 6:19-cv-00317-MC, 6:19-cv-00318-MC (cp) (Entered: 05/06/2019)

US motion for stay pending appeal, May 10, 2019

9C Oregon US mo for stay

 

American Medical Ass’n v. Azar, No. 6:19-cv-318 (D. Or.)

Complaint, March 5, 2019

6521308-0–25286

Motion for preliminary injunction, March 21, 2019

6542527-0–10251

Custer declaration

 

Gardner declaration

 

Udall declaration

 

Ewing declaration

 

Megregian declaration

 

Williams declaration

 

Madara declaration

 

Atkinson declaration

 

Black declaration

 

Brindis declaration

 

Kost declaration

 

Amicus brief

 

 

WASHINGTON

State of Washington v. Azar, No. 1:19-cv-3040 (E.D. Wash)

Complaint, March 5, 2019

Wash v Azar Title X complaint

Unopposed consolidation motion, March 18, 2019

WvA motion to consolidate

Consolidation and expedition order, March 18, 2019

WvA consolidation expedition order

State’s motion for preliminary injunction with proposed order, March 22, 2019

WvA pi mo and proposed order

Eastlund declaration

 

Harris declaration

 

Khattar declaration

 

Kimelman declaration

 

Marsalli declaration

 

Schumacher declaration

 

Beneski declaration, with attachments

 

Amicus brief Am Academy of Pediatrics, April ? 9, 2019

Am Academy Pediatrics amicus

Amicus brief Inst Policy Integrity, April ? 10, 2019

Institute for Policy Integrity amicus

Amicus brief Ohio, April ? 12, 2019

Ohio amicus

US opposition to motion for preliminary injunction, April 12, 2019

US op to PI

Private plaintiffs’ preliminary injunction reply, April 19, 2019

private plaintiffs PI reply

State’s preliminary injunction reply, April 19, 2019

state’s PI reply

Order for preliminary injunction, April 25, 2019

Order for PI

Defendants’ notice re conscience regulations, May 2, 2019

Defendants’ notice re conscience regs

Notice of appeal, May 3, 2019

Notice of appeal

Motion to stay pending appeal, with affidavit and proposed order, May 3, 2019

Motion to stay pending appeal

Motion to expedite hearing on motion to stay, May 3, 2019

Motion to expedite hearing on motion to stay

Errata: Johnson declaration, proposed order, May 4, 2019

Notice of errata

Johnson declaration

Proposed stay order

Ninth Circuit # 19-35394

Response to motion to expedite, May 6, 2019

Response to motion to expedite

05/07/2019 66 TEXT ORDER: Defendants’ Motion to Expedite, ECF No. 59 , is DENIED. The hearing set for May 10, 2019 on Defendant’s Motion to Stay, ECF No. 58 , is continued to May 23, 2019. The deadline for filing Plaintiffs’ response to Defendant’s Motion to Stay is May 17, 2019. The deadline for any reply is May 22, 2019. Signed by Judge Stanley A Bastian. Text entry; no PDF document will issue. This text-only entry constitutes the court order on the matter. (LR, Case Administrator) (Entered: 05/07/2019)

US motion to stay (Ninth Circuit), May 13, 2019

9C Washington v. Azar US mo to stay

Response to motion to stay (State), May 17, 2019

Wash v Azar state stay op

Response to motion to stay (private), May 17, 2019

Wash v Azar private stay op

 

National Family Planning & Reproductive Health Ass’n v. Azar, No. 1:19-cv-3045 (E.D. Wash.)

Complaint, March 5, 2019

NFP RH A v. Azar Complaint

Motion for preliminary injunction, with proposed order, March 22, 2019, filed in 3040

NF PI mo

Coleman declaration

 

Kost declaration

 

Cantrell declaration

 

Adams declaration

 

Kruse declaration

 

Madden declaration

 

Maisen declaration

 

Prager declaration